Criterion Channel Surfing, Episode 22: Films from Underrepresented Countries on Other Streaming Services

Josh is joined once again by Doug McCambridge of the Good Time, Great Movies podcast – as well as the new Schitt’s and Giggles podcast – to discuss films from underrepresented countries on other streaming services.

Where to Find Us Online

An American Pickle (2020) | Directed by Brandon Trost

2/5
Brandon Trost’s An American Pickel is a comedy with so much promise that is squandered on a narrative that never fully commits to any of the 15 different directions it tries to take and stumbles so terribly in the final act that there’s no possibility for it to recover. While it hits all the beats of a traditional Seth Rogan bromance, the connective tissue that gets us from beat to beat is missing, leaving the entire experience unsatisfying. And then there are these feints into Being There territory – the moments they almost pull off a great satire on American politics and what it means to confront the ugliness of American history – but the filmmakers are never willing to commit to a theme or an idea and see it through to the end. The final attempt at pathos and heart-tugging is manipulative, cloying, and unearned – ripping us out of the story they’ve been trying to tell. Yes, there are a few sweet moments and bits of humor scattered throughout, but it’s a deeply flawed film that could had the potential to be so much more.

Where to Watch

Criterion Channel Surfing, Episode 21: Around the World

Josh is joined once again by Doug McCambridge of the Good Time, Great Movies podcast – as well as the new Schitt’s and Giggles podcast – to discuss films from underrepresented countries on the Criterion Channel. Plus, Matt Gasteier from The Complete Podcast returns to give a refresher on basic navigation and discuss common concerns for anyone who might be new to the channel.

Where to Find Us Online

Young Ahmed (2019) | Directed by the Dardenne Brothers

4.5/5

The Dardenne brothers’ Young Ahmed is a gut-wrenching, deeply poignant look at radicalization and the ways desperate young people can be held under the sway of charismatic authority figures – especially in religious communities. Like so many of their other work, the effortless, almost documentary realism makes the film appear simpler than it is. The loose, handheld camerawork and long sequence shots are meticulously crafted and perfectly constructed – to heighten suspense and tension in some scenes, to bring us to profound emotional catharsis in others. And I appreciate the ways in which they attempt to show the breadth of Muslim experience in this community – especially since so much of the film focuses on a radicalized Muslim teenager. It’s a work filled with the Dardenne brothers’ deep humanist compassion for everyone – even for characters who attempt terrible things. It’s a beautiful, deeply moving film.

Where to Watch

Criterion Channel Surfing, Episode 20: July 2020 New and Expiring Titles

Josh is joined by Doug McCambridge of the Good Time, Great Movies podcast – as well as the new Schitt’s and Giggles podcast – to discuss July’s new and expiring titles. Plus, Michael Hutchins stops by to talk about the digital supplements created exclusively for the Criterion Channel.

Where to Find Us Online

Palm Springs (2020) | Directed by Max Barbakow

4/5
Max Barbakow’s Palm Springs is a thoroughly enjoyable addition to the time loop comedy genre. It’s especially refreshing to have the narrative handed off between the two leads, allowing us genuine moments of surprise as the story is told from multiple viewpoints. The comedy is tightly executed and just absurd enough to work within the premise without ever spinning too far out of control. Samberg and Milioti play off one another beautifully, and J.K. Simmons makes for a perfect third player. As the film reaches its conclusion, the script does try to explain the “science” of the scenario more than is needed, bogging down the final act with nonsensical particle physics for dummies. But in reaching for an explanation, the film does provide some nice moments for Milioti’s character as she tries to take control of her life and navigate this endless purgatory. Even though it was made long before the pandemic was a blip on our radar, it’s the perfect film for this moment, stuck inside during a health crisis for months on end in an endless repetition of the same routines, reaching out beyond our wall, looking for connection.

Where to Watch

Da 5 Bloods (2020) | Directed by Spike Lee

5/5
Spike Lee’s Da 5 Bloods is absolutely incredible – another masterpiece from one of America’s greatest living filmmakers. As he’s done so beautifully in recent years, Lee draws such clearly defined lines between the past and the present, working in archival footage, fictional narrative, pseudo-documentary, and direct address to craft a rich narrative quilt that looks at the legacies of racial and colonial violence, deep generational trauma, and the communal effort it takes to heal and rebuild from these deep wounds. And the fact that it’s all wrapped up in a rip-roaring adventure story makes such incendiary material more accessible for the average viewer than it otherwise would be. Working with an impressive cast of Lee veterans and newcomers alike, the filmmaker and the performers are all working at the top of their game – especially Delroy Lindo who gives a career best performance in a lifetime of incredible work. Like so many of Spike Lee’s films, it manages to be both highly experimental in form and deeply moving in its content. As I continue to dig into his filmography, I continue to be astounded by Lee’s work.

Where to Watch

Criterion Channel Surfing, Episode 19: June 2020 New and Expiring Titles, Film Noir, HBO Max, and Bergman Entry Points

On this mega-episode of the podcast, Josh is joined by Brad McDermott, filmmaker and frequent guest on the Criterion Reflections and Criterion Now podcasts, to discuss films noir in the Criterion Channel’s permanent library, as well as the new and expiring titles for the month of June. Michael Hutchins stops by to discuss the Criterion titles on Warner Media’s new streaming service, HBO Max, and Becky D’Anna joins Josh for a conversation about entry points to the films of Ingmar Bergman.

Where to Find Us Online

Hamilton (2020) | Directed by Thomas Kail

4.5/5
Thomas Kail’s Hamilton is an effective and deeply moving recording of the stage production, capturing so much of the energy, evocative and highly theatrical staging, and thoroughly compelling performances that are only part of what’s made it such a phenomenon. Of course, with all the hype, it has a lot to live up to – more than any work of art can possibly be burdened with – but it still manages to be thoroughly engaging. It’s refreshing to see the ways that writer Lin Manuel Miranda allows the United States’ founders to be fully human – petty, vain, idealistic, naïve, and very wrong sometimes. And the way the play interrogates the idea of who gets to shape our narratives – of a nation’s history or even a person’s history – adds more thought and nuance to its layers than many of our modern musicals. Even though the financial side of a recording like this is highly impractical on a wide scale, it would be nice to see this open the door for more theatrical recordings-on-film to make their way to the general public. Increasing accessibility to this art form through digital technology may be imperfect, but there’s something beautiful about increasing accessibility to productions that people would never be able to see due to geographic, physical, or financial limitations.

Where to Watch

Family Romance, LLC (2019) | Directed by Werner Herzog

4.5/5
Werner Herzog’s Family Romance, LLC is a Herzog film through and through, complete with the auteur’s obsessions about the blurred lines between performance and reality, as well as his penchant for narrative digressions and his delight in the imperfections that arise in the filmmaking process. Made on a tiny budget, the film’s handmade aesthetic and use of non traditional actors (mostly playing themselves and recreating and improvising situations similar to ones they’ve encountered) creates an eerie space where fiction and reality blur, placing us within the uncanny valley – where the approximation of real life is off just enough to keep us off balance and unsettled for the duration of the film. It’s a space where Herzog thrives. And he’s found the perfect collaborators in this film that asks us to question what it means to truly connect with another human being in an age where we’re so disconnected. As postmodern and intellectual as it is, Herzog and his cast never lose sight of the humanity at the center of these questions. It’s an approach that makes the film deeply moving and a work of incredible beauty.

Where to Watch